Question:
In early March, wife and I want to train it from Lugano, Switzerland to Venice. Two days later train it to Salzburg, Austria. In reading the thread, it sounds like you all recommend buying the tickets on site instead of a pre-bought pass. Am I correct in my assumption?
No need to calculate as those rather short trips are by far less expensive with buying tickets on site compared with railpasses. Plus, I am, unfortunately, only an English speaker. Would anyone know if there is enough "English" around in Lugano and Venice train stations for me to walk in and figure this out fairly easily? We will be looking for the highest speed trains, as time is an issue. We have been to Zurich and Geneva and gotten along quite well. Thanks.
Don’t think there are any problems using English (I’ve experience of Venice) If not be prepared to make your request written. There are no high speed trains on those routes as they are through mountains but they’re real scenic. L.P
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
It is not necessary to buy rail tickets in the train station. You can buy them at travel agents. Several days ahead of time. Also if the line is long in Roma’s Termini station, I just go to the travel agent inside the station. Marianne
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets. With the caveat to be sure to get the realistic prices. The point-to-point fares shown on almost all travel agent sites, even RailEurope, are inflated and are only for certain higer fares, rather like only quoting the full coach fare on an airplane. For instance, I just did a quick look at Rick Steves’ web site where he has a map showing fares between many points for comparison with the cost of a pass (which he sells). Steve’s indicates a fare of EUR 105 from Berlin to Frankfurt while the DB web site shows the fare as EUR 86, and that fare is without any of the available discounts or Bahncards. RailEurope gives this fare as $96 (EUR 100). For fares inside a given country the country’s national rail web site is the best source of fare information, although some can be a bit difficult even in the English pages (if they have English pages). Sweden seems to have made a point of making it difficult to get fares from afar. On the other hand, the Finnish rail site is a model of lucidity (although I don’t seem to be able to properly download its fare calcultor pages recently). Trips between countries can be difficult to ferret out. Some national web sites do give fares for international fares originating in that country, e.g., the French rail site gives fares from inside Paris to other countries, and will even price out journeys requiring a change of trains in the other country. Some "cheating" is requirted at some sites; e.g., at the French site pretend you are actually trying to book a ticket and you will pick up the ticket inside France. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train. If the pass will only cost a bit more than point-to-point fares, go for the pass. There is a freedom you get from not worrying about having to dig out some more euros and wondering if your budget can afford it. Also, with a pass you are likely to make more rail journeys than you anticipated in making your calcs, so that in the end you may actually save rail fares with a pass and have a better time. The full Eurailpass is good for this sort of travel, while the flexipasses (x days in y weeks) may have you wondering whether you can afford to use up a day on the little side trip you’d like to make. * Tucson Arizona, out where the cacti grow * * My typos & mispellings are intentional copyright traps *
As you all are much more informed on this than I, may I run something past you, please? In early March, wife and I want to train it from Lugano, Switzerland to Venice. Two days later train it to Salzburg, Austria. In reading the thread, it sounds like you all recommend buying the tickets on site instead of a pre-bought pass. Am I correct in my assumption? Plus, I am, unfortunately, only an English speaker. Would anyone know if there is enough "English" around in Lugano and Venice train stations for me to walk in and figure this out fairly easily? We will be looking for the highest speed trains, as time is an issue. We have been to Zurich and Geneva and gotten along quite well. Thanks. — Rich www.headachedrugs.com
Response:
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini.
Hm! If it wasn’t you, Barbara, I’d be tempted to reply that you must not go there much. When I’ve been there in the summer, the lines were literally hours long. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September)
It’s true, it varies by time of year. Summer can be very, very bad. Made the mistake of once relying on that station for validating my Eurail pass before first use–five hour wait. Me and my travelling companions spent lots of time in the McDonalds upstairs. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets.
With the caveat to be sure to get the realistic prices. The point-to-point fares shown on almost all travel agent sites, even RailEurope, are inflated and are only for certain higer fares, rather like only quoting the full coach fare on an airplane. For instance, I just did a quick look at Rick Steves’ web site where he has a map showing fares between many points for comparison with the cost of a pass (which he sells). Steve’s indicates a fare of EUR 105 from Berlin to Frankfurt while the DB web site shows the fare as EUR 86, and that fare is without any of the available discounts or Bahncards. RailEurope gives this fare as $96 (EUR 100). For fares inside a given country the country’s national rail web site is the best source of fare information, although some can be a bit difficult even in the English pages (if they have English pages). Sweden seems to have made a point of making it difficult to get fares from afar. On the other hand, the Finnish rail site is a model of lucidity (although I don’t seem to be able to properly download its fare calcultor pages recently). Trips between countries can be difficult to ferret out. Some national web sites do give fares for international fares originating in that country, e.g., the French rail site gives fares from inside Paris to other countries, and will even price out journeys requiring a change of trains in the other country. Some "cheating" is requirted at some sites; e.g., at the French site pretend you are actually trying to book a ticket and you will pick up the ticket inside France. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train.
If the pass will only cost a bit more than point-to-point fares, go for the pass. There is a freedom you get from not worrying about having to dig out some more euros and wondering if your budget can afford it. Also, with a pass you are likely to make more rail journeys than you anticipated in making your calcs, so that in the end you may actually save rail fares with a pass and have a better time. The full Eurailpass is good for this sort of travel, while the flexipasses (x days in y weeks) may have you wondering whether you can afford to use up a day on the little side trip you’d like to make. * Tucson Arizona, out where the cacti grow * * My typos & mispellings are intentional copyright traps *
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September)
Went in there (the international area upstairs) a few days ago and there was a 45-minute wait. miguel — Hit The Road! Photos and tales from around the world: http://travel.u.nu Latest addition: 80 photos from Guatemala
Response:
local train. Typically, to get to smaller town, you take an express train to a hub city and a local train from there. For example, to get to Pisa you’ll probably have to go through Florence.
Pisa is on the main line Genova-Rome! I would suggest anyone travelling by Eurail-Interrail to buy a good rail-map, perhaps Thomas Cooks Rail Map of Europe including close to all European railwaylines. L.P
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train. All you destinations are great. If you’re going past Florence, you should take in the Uffizzi art gallery in a day. In Pisa, do not miss the baptistry – stick around long enough, and they close the doors and give a singing performance – very nice, as the acoustics are so perfect that one’s voice carries for a long time, enabling one to sing with oneself in harmony. Local trains mean trains that are slower and stop at every little town. This is different from the fast express trains that go to main hubs. The trains in Germany are great, in that there are little kiosks everywhere where you put in your departure and arrival place and time, and it tells you all your training options. I remember clearly in one instance where I could leave an hour later on an inter-city express (ICE) than on a local train, but get there an hour earlier than the local train. Typically, to get to smaller town, you take an express train to a hub city and a local train from there. For example, to get to Pisa you’ll probably have to go through Florence. Dan — Dan Stephenson Grand Tour photos and video: http://homepage.mac.com/stepheda
Response:
On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Discounts for groups traveling together in Italian trains have changed recently and are much less convenient than used to be. Now to get a smaller discount the group has to be at least 6 passengers traveling together to get a 20% discount (10% on Eurostar Italia) or 2 adults traveling with one children under 12 yo.(in this case the children will not pay). Not as good as before when there was a 30% discount for any group of 3 to 5 passengers traveling together. Elio
Response:
On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Discounts for groups traveling together in Italian trains have changed recently and are much less convenient than used to be. Now to get a smaller discount the group has to be at least 6 passengers traveling together to get a 20% discount (10% on Eurostar Italia) or 2 adults traveling with one children under 12 yo.(in this case the children will not pay). Not as good as before when there was a 30% discount for any group of 3 to 5 passengers traveling together. Regards Elio
Response:
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini. Now that they have ticket machines, you don’t have to spend any time in line. While the convenience may be worth something, buying a Eurail pass for travel in Italy might mean that 70% of the cost of the pass would be spent on convenience and 30% on transport.
I bought my first and only Eurailpass in 1961, for $125, good 3 months, first class. Even then, the only way I made it pay was to be constantly on the move. Strictly speaking, I’m not eligible for Eurailpasses anymore because I live in Europe. I do buy 1/2 fare subscriptions if I’m going to be in a country awhile. Notably in Belgium. (Switzerland 1-month passes aren’t a good by IMO, but 2-year passes are a bargain. You just need a Swiss address.)
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow)
Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September) Phil
Response:
You can get schedules on http://www.trenitalia.it
I have found this site to be both difficult and sometimes not up to date. The German European timetables at http://www.bahn.de/ are the best Phil
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini. Now that they have ticket machines, you don’t have to spend any time in line. While the convenience may be worth something, buying a Eurail pass for travel in Italy might mean that 70% of the cost of the pass would be spent on convenience and 30% on transport. Barbara
Response:
In my opinion, Eurail passes are no longer the bargain they used to be, especially if you’re travelling in Italy. The train tickets there are so cheap it’s ridiculous. If you’re coming from Innsbruck, why not plan to visit Venice? It’s one of the must-see places in Europe and it’s practically next door. You can skip Pisa. There’s nothing there but a leaning tower. Otherwise it’s a not too attractive blue collar town. Turin is a little better, but if you’re venturing into that area, I’d recommend the Cinque Terre, on the coast between Pisa and Genoa. Portofino is also just north of there. It’s a beautiful area. Eurial passes are only a deal if you’re you plan to travel several long distance trips in a short amount of time. In your case, I can’t imagine a pass being cheaper than single tickets.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
There are quite a nunmber of different passes, the traditional Eurail Pass beding about the MOST expensive. Some offer any N days out of M days in one or a few countries, often available in second as well as first class. Some include a few days of rental car, not necessarily sequential. There are lots of variations.
That’s why I said if you can afford it–sounds like the OP will be doing lots of travelling, and a 2 week Eurail pass is the deluxe option for that–you won’t run out of travelling days. Most of the other ones are offered by country, which is awkward if you’re moving a lot. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
There are quite a nunmber of different passes, the traditional Eurail Pass beding about the MOST expensive. Some offer any N days out of M days in one or a few countries, often available in second as well as first class. Some include a few days of rental car, not necessarily sequential. There are lots of variations. Unless you’re going to see more of trains rather than of the "sights", one of the other passes generally makes more sense.
Response:
I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains?
Italian trains are inexpensive. You can get schedules on http://www.trenitalia.it . Prices may also be listed. You can buy tickets at the train stations. You may want to record the schedules and bring them on the trip. Eurostar (ES*) trains are the fastest and have all reserved seating. IC trains have some reserved seating available for an extra charge. Prices do get higher for faster trains, so if you have a pass, you may have to pay extra to use the faster trains. On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Response:
Hi, I *usually* tend to vacation in only one or two countries at a time, and so I find that individual country passes are cheaper than Eurail. This can be especially true when travelling with someone, as you can get a "twin pass" which lowers the cost even more. I try to rough out my itinerary, use a website (like DB’s: http://www.bahn.de/pv/uebersicht/die_bahn_international_guests.shtml ) to get an idea of the ballpark cost of individual tickets and then decide from there. If you have the time, there are some GREAT books about European train travel that you can get from the library, that cover each country and how it all works with tips and advice (and it’s free!). Have a great time!!
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
The following webpage will help you decide: http://www.ricksteves.com/rail/home.htm Barbara in CT – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains?
The only way to find out is to price your proposed route and compare it with the cost of a pass. Let’s Go Europe (and perhaps other guidebooks) has a chart of second class basic train fares between various European cities. While you may not find the exact cities you want, you can usually find something nearby and the price should be similar. You might want to add about 10 – 20% to this estimate for upgrades to trains more expensive than basic fare but still covered by Eurail passes, for unplanned trips, and for the convenience factor. Some trains will require that you buy a supplement or mandatory reserved seats even if you have a Eurail pass. If you are under 26 and can get the 2nd class (youth) Eurail pass, you are more likely to see a savings. However, Italian train fares are quite low and it almost never pays to use a Eurail pass for travel mostly in Italy, even if it’s a youth pass. Whatever you do, don’t compare the price of a pass with the cost of point-to-point tickets offered by raileurope or other American vendors of European train tickets. These are greatly inflated. Barbara
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice.
It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains?
Italian trains are inexpensive. You can get schedules on http://www.trenitalia.it . Prices may also be listed. You can buy tickets at the train stations. You may want to record the schedules and bring them on the trip. Eurostar (ES*) trains are the fastest and have all reserved seating. IC trains have some reserved seating available for an extra charge. Prices do get higher for faster trains, so if you have a pass, you may have to pay extra to use the faster trains. On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Response:
Hi, I *usually* tend to vacation in only one or two countries at a time, and so I find that individual country passes are cheaper than Eurail. This can be especially true when travelling with someone, as you can get a "twin pass" which lowers the cost even more. I try to rough out my itinerary, use a website (like DB’s: http://www.bahn.de/pv/uebersicht/die_bahn_international_guests.shtml ) to get an idea of the ballpark cost of individual tickets and then decide from there. If you have the time, there are some GREAT books about European train travel that you can get from the library, that cover each country and how it all works with tips and advice (and it’s free!). Have a great time!!
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
The following webpage will help you decide: http://www.ricksteves.com/rail/home.htm Barbara in CT – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains?
The only way to find out is to price your proposed route and compare it with the cost of a pass. Let’s Go Europe (and perhaps other guidebooks) has a chart of second class basic train fares between various European cities. While you may not find the exact cities you want, you can usually find something nearby and the price should be similar. You might want to add about 10 – 20% to this estimate for upgrades to trains more expensive than basic fare but still covered by Eurail passes, for unplanned trips, and for the convenience factor. Some trains will require that you buy a supplement or mandatory reserved seats even if you have a Eurail pass. If you are under 26 and can get the 2nd class (youth) Eurail pass, you are more likely to see a savings. However, Italian train fares are quite low and it almost never pays to use a Eurail pass for travel mostly in Italy, even if it’s a youth pass. Whatever you do, don’t compare the price of a pass with the cost of point-to-point tickets offered by raileurope or other American vendors of European train tickets. These are greatly inflated. Barbara
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice.
It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
There are quite a nunmber of different passes, the traditional Eurail Pass beding about the MOST expensive. Some offer any N days out of M days in one or a few countries, often available in second as well as first class. Some include a few days of rental car, not necessarily sequential. There are lots of variations. Unless you’re going to see more of trains rather than of the "sights", one of the other passes generally makes more sense.
Response:
There are quite a nunmber of different passes, the traditional Eurail Pass beding about the MOST expensive. Some offer any N days out of M days in one or a few countries, often available in second as well as first class. Some include a few days of rental car, not necessarily sequential. There are lots of variations.
That’s why I said if you can afford it–sounds like the OP will be doing lots of travelling, and a 2 week Eurail pass is the deluxe option for that–you won’t run out of travelling days. Most of the other ones are offered by country, which is awkward if you’re moving a lot. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
In my opinion, Eurail passes are no longer the bargain they used to be, especially if you’re travelling in Italy. The train tickets there are so cheap it’s ridiculous. If you’re coming from Innsbruck, why not plan to visit Venice? It’s one of the must-see places in Europe and it’s practically next door. You can skip Pisa. There’s nothing there but a leaning tower. Otherwise it’s a not too attractive blue collar town. Turin is a little better, but if you’re venturing into that area, I’d recommend the Cinque Terre, on the coast between Pisa and Genoa. Portofino is also just north of there. It’s a beautiful area. Eurial passes are only a deal if you’re you plan to travel several long distance trips in a short amount of time. In your case, I can’t imagine a pass being cheaper than single tickets.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini. Now that they have ticket machines, you don’t have to spend any time in line. While the convenience may be worth something, buying a Eurail pass for travel in Italy might mean that 70% of the cost of the pass would be spent on convenience and 30% on transport. Barbara
Response:
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini. Now that they have ticket machines, you don’t have to spend any time in line. While the convenience may be worth something, buying a Eurail pass for travel in Italy might mean that 70% of the cost of the pass would be spent on convenience and 30% on transport.
I bought my first and only Eurailpass in 1961, for $125, good 3 months, first class. Even then, the only way I made it pay was to be constantly on the move. Strictly speaking, I’m not eligible for Eurailpasses anymore because I live in Europe. I do buy 1/2 fare subscriptions if I’m going to be in a country awhile. Notably in Belgium. (Switzerland 1-month passes aren’t a good by IMO, but 2-year passes are a bargain. You just need a Swiss address.)
Response:
I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. PS if any one has been to these citties and can recomend things to see or places to avoid – or for that matter other citties to see, your input is welcome Thank you
The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train. All you destinations are great. If you’re going past Florence, you should take in the Uffizzi art gallery in a day. In Pisa, do not miss the baptistry – stick around long enough, and they close the doors and give a singing performance – very nice, as the acoustics are so perfect that one’s voice carries for a long time, enabling one to sing with oneself in harmony. Local trains mean trains that are slower and stop at every little town. This is different from the fast express trains that go to main hubs. The trains in Germany are great, in that there are little kiosks everywhere where you put in your departure and arrival place and time, and it tells you all your training options. I remember clearly in one instance where I could leave an hour later on an inter-city express (ICE) than on a local train, but get there an hour earlier than the local train. Typically, to get to smaller town, you take an express train to a hub city and a local train from there. For example, to get to Pisa you’ll probably have to go through Florence. Dan — Dan Stephenson Grand Tour photos and video: http://homepage.mac.com/stepheda
Response:
You can get schedules on http://www.trenitalia.it
I have found this site to be both difficult and sometimes not up to date. The German European timetables at http://www.bahn.de/ are the best Phil
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow)
Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September) Phil
Response:
local train. Typically, to get to smaller town, you take an express train to a hub city and a local train from there. For example, to get to Pisa you’ll probably have to go through Florence.
Pisa is on the main line Genova-Rome! I would suggest anyone travelling by Eurail-Interrail to buy a good rail-map, perhaps Thomas Cooks Rail Map of Europe including close to all European railwaylines. L.P
Response:
On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Discounts for groups traveling together in Italian trains have changed recently and are much less convenient than used to be. Now to get a smaller discount the group has to be at least 6 passengers traveling together to get a 20% discount (10% on Eurostar Italia) or 2 adults traveling with one children under 12 yo.(in this case the children will not pay). Not as good as before when there was a 30% discount for any group of 3 to 5 passengers traveling together. Regards Elio
Response:
On some types of trains, a group traveling together can get a group discount (resulting in one ticket being issued for the group, rather than a bunch of individual tickets). — Timothy J. Lee Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome. No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.
Discounts for groups traveling together in Italian trains have changed recently and are much less convenient than used to be. Now to get a smaller discount the group has to be at least 6 passengers traveling together to get a 20% discount (10% on Eurostar Italia) or 2 adults traveling with one children under 12 yo.(in this case the children will not pay). Not as good as before when there was a 30% discount for any group of 3 to 5 passengers traveling together. Elio
Response:
I have never spent more than five minutes in line at Termini.
Hm! If it wasn’t you, Barbara, I’d be tempted to reply that you must not go there much. When I’ve been there in the summer, the lines were literally hours long. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September)
It’s true, it varies by time of year. Summer can be very, very bad. Made the mistake of once relying on that station for validating my Eurail pass before first use–five hour wait. Me and my travelling companions spent lots of time in the McDonalds upstairs. A truly cool book: The World Is Already Yours Conscious living in the real world www.alreadyyours.com (sample chapter, etc…)
Response:
…..Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) Not in my experience (latest use of Centraal Station was in September)
Went in there (the international area upstairs) a few days ago and there was a 45-minute wait. miguel — Hit The Road! Photos and tales from around the world: http://travel.u.nu Latest addition: 80 photos from Guatemala
Response:
The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets.
With the caveat to be sure to get the realistic prices. The point-to-point fares shown on almost all travel agent sites, even RailEurope, are inflated and are only for certain higer fares, rather like only quoting the full coach fare on an airplane. For instance, I just did a quick look at Rick Steves’ web site where he has a map showing fares between many points for comparison with the cost of a pass (which he sells). Steve’s indicates a fare of EUR 105 from Berlin to Frankfurt while the DB web site shows the fare as EUR 86, and that fare is without any of the available discounts or Bahncards. RailEurope gives this fare as $96 (EUR 100). For fares inside a given country the country’s national rail web site is the best source of fare information, although some can be a bit difficult even in the English pages (if they have English pages). Sweden seems to have made a point of making it difficult to get fares from afar. On the other hand, the Finnish rail site is a model of lucidity (although I don’t seem to be able to properly download its fare calcultor pages recently). Trips between countries can be difficult to ferret out. Some national web sites do give fares for international fares originating in that country, e.g., the French rail site gives fares from inside Paris to other countries, and will even price out journeys requiring a change of trains in the other country. Some "cheating" is requirted at some sites; e.g., at the French site pretend you are actually trying to book a ticket and you will pick up the ticket inside France. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train.
If the pass will only cost a bit more than point-to-point fares, go for the pass. There is a freedom you get from not worrying about having to dig out some more euros and wondering if your budget can afford it. Also, with a pass you are likely to make more rail journeys than you anticipated in making your calcs, so that in the end you may actually save rail fares with a pass and have a better time. The full Eurailpass is good for this sort of travel, while the flexipasses (x days in y weeks) may have you wondering whether you can afford to use up a day on the little side trip you’d like to make. * Tucson Arizona, out where the cacti grow * * My typos & mispellings are intentional copyright traps *
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I plan on traveling for 2 weeks in Europe and plan to go from Austria (Innsbruck) to Italy (Probably Rome, Pisa and/or Turin) the Travel to Paris and Amsterdam, finally ending up in Munich. I hear that in Italy the local rali service is good and it’s not worth getting a Euro Rail pass for there. Is this true and is it then really worth getting the pass at all or will the local trains do? Also what do they mean by local trains? Thanks in advance for any advice. It depends–if you can afford it, get one. Otherwise you’ll be spending hours in train stations (in particular, Rome’s Termini and Amsterdam’s Centraal Station, of the ones you indicate, these are very slow) waiting in line, waiting in line, waiting in line, and finally buying tickets. Nice to have the freedom of the pass and jump on when you want (assuming there are non-reserved seats). It’s NOT just a matter of cost.
It is not necessary to buy rail tickets in the train station. You can buy them at travel agents. Several days ahead of time. Also if the line is long in Roma’s Termini station, I just go to the travel agent inside the station. Marianne
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The general advice is to compare the price of a rail pass to the cost of individual tickets. With the caveat to be sure to get the realistic prices. The point-to-point fares shown on almost all travel agent sites, even RailEurope, are inflated and are only for certain higer fares, rather like only quoting the full coach fare on an airplane. For instance, I just did a quick look at Rick Steves’ web site where he has a map showing fares between many points for comparison with the cost of a pass (which he sells). Steve’s indicates a fare of EUR 105 from Berlin to Frankfurt while the DB web site shows the fare as EUR 86, and that fare is without any of the available discounts or Bahncards. RailEurope gives this fare as $96 (EUR 100). For fares inside a given country the country’s national rail web site is the best source of fare information, although some can be a bit difficult even in the English pages (if they have English pages). Sweden seems to have made a point of making it difficult to get fares from afar. On the other hand, the Finnish rail site is a model of lucidity (although I don’t seem to be able to properly download its fare calcultor pages recently). Trips between countries can be difficult to ferret out. Some national web sites do give fares for international fares originating in that country, e.g., the French rail site gives fares from inside Paris to other countries, and will even price out journeys requiring a change of trains in the other country. Some "cheating" is requirted at some sites; e.g., at the French site pretend you are actually trying to book a ticket and you will pick up the ticket inside France. Secondarily, I for one would pay more for a pass just so I did not have to bother with the act of buying tickets. Sometimes ticket lines are long, and it is really nice to be able to just hop on a train. If the pass will only cost a bit more than point-to-point fares, go for the pass. There is a freedom you get from not worrying about having to dig out some more euros and wondering if your budget can afford it. Also, with a pass you are likely to make more rail journeys than you anticipated in making your calcs, so that in the end you may actually save rail fares with a pass and have a better time. The full Eurailpass is good for this sort of travel, while the flexipasses (x days in y weeks) may have you wondering whether you can afford to use up a day on the little side trip you’d like to make. * Tucson Arizona, out where the cacti grow * * My typos & mispellings are intentional copyright traps *
As you all are much more informed on this than I, may I run something past you, please? In early March, wife and I want to train it from Lugano, Switzerland to Venice. Two days later train it to Salzburg, Austria. In reading the thread, it sounds like you all recommend buying the tickets on site instead of a pre-bought pass. Am I correct in my assumption? Plus, I am, unfortunately, only an English speaker. Would anyone know if there is enough "English" around in Lugano and Venice train stations for me to walk in and figure this out fairly easily? We will be looking for the highest speed trains, as time is an issue. We have been to Zurich and Geneva and gotten along quite well. Thanks. — Rich www.headachedrugs.com
Response:
In early March, wife and I want to train it from Lugano, Switzerland to Venice. Two days later train it to Salzburg, Austria. In reading the thread, it sounds like you all recommend buying the tickets on site instead of a pre-bought pass. Am I correct in my assumption?
No need to calculate as those rather short trips are by far less expensive with buying tickets on site compared with railpasses. Plus, I am, unfortunately, only an English speaker. Would anyone know if there is enough "English" around in Lugano and Venice train stations for me to walk in and figure this out fairly easily? We will be looking for the highest speed trains, as time is an issue. We have been to Zurich and Geneva and gotten along quite well. Thanks.
Don’t think there are any problems using English (I’ve experience of Venice) If not be prepared to make your request written. There are no high speed trains on those routes as they are through mountains but they’re real scenic. L.P
Response: